Destroying
the �Republicans Are Better for Defense Stocks� Myth
By Charles L. Norton, CFA Portfolio Manager
With the Presidential election gathering steam, I wanted to
take a moment to try and debunk a commonly held � but way
off-base � view that Republicans are better for defense stocks
than Democrats. This myth, originating during the Reagan years,
I believe, is just not supported by the data.
Election-Year Performance
Weighs In
First consider the historical election-year performance of
the defense sector. The S&P; 500 Aerospace/Defense Index has
outperformed the S&P; 500 in all four of the election years
since 1992 by an average of 12.5% 1;
two of those elections, recall, resulted in Clinton victories.
Goldman Sachs has data going back even further that shows
that the defense sector has outperformed the S&P; in seven
of the eight Presidential election years since 1976 by an
average of over 20%. 2
Both of those data points infer that defense stocks tend to
outperform the broader market in Presidential election years,
regardless of political party. If the pattern persists, 2008
could be another strong year for the defense sector. 3
A close examination of the defense-budget data shows that
historically, budget authority on procurement and Research,
Development, Test, and Evaluation (RDT&E;) � one of the most
important factor driving defense stocks � grows at just about
the same annual rate regardless of which political party is
in the White House. In fact, it has historically grown at
a slightly faster clip when a Democrat is in office.
The Congressional Effect
Of course, that analysis is a bit complicated by the impact
of Congress. Taking the same thought further down Pennsylvania
Avenue, I took a look at the correlation between Republican
representation in Congress and budget authority on procurement
and RDT&E; � often called �modernization spending� or the �investment
account� � and found it to be zero. In other words, Republican
representation in Congress does not appear to be at all predictive
of modernization spending.
So the bottom line is that, contrary to the widely held (but
apparently seldom analyzed) view that the defense sector fares
better with a Republican president, that appears to be nothing
more than a myth that the data simply doesn�t support. With
that in mind, in the Vice Fund we continue to have a favorable
outlook for the defense sector, largely founded on our outlook
of growth in the defense budget � regardless of who wins this
year�s election.
1 These figures were compiled by GNI Capital using data from
Bloomberg. It compares the return data for the S&P; 500 Aerospace
& Defense Index during the full calendar year in which there
is a Presidential election to the return of the S&P; 500 Index
over the same time period.
2 Goldman Sachs, �Buy defense; avoid major pain � raising
coverage view to Attractive,� Nov. 27, 2007
3 There is no guarantee that the pattern noted will persist
in 2008. There are many factors that drive stock returns and,
in fact, for any number of reasons defense stocks might underperform
in 2008.
Mutual fund investing involves risk; principal loss
is possible. The Fund is nondiversified, meaning it may concentrate
its assets in fewer individual holdings than a diversified
fund. Therefore, the Fund is more exposed to individual stock
volatility than a diversified fund. The Fund invests in foreign
securities which involve greater volatility and political,
economic and currency risks and differences in accounting
methods. The Fund also invests in smaller companies, which
involve additional risks such as limited liquidity and greater
volatility.
Opinions expressed are those of Charles Norton, and is not
intended to be a forecast of future events, a guarantee of
future results, nor investment advice.
Fund holdings and sector allocations are subject to change
and are not recommendations to buy or sell any security.
The S&P; 500 Aerospace & Defense Index is a capitalization-weighted
index of large-cap aerospace and defense companies.
The S&P; 500 Index is a broad based unmanaged index of 500
stocks, which is widely recognized as representative of the
equity market in general. You cannot invest directly in an
index.
The funds' investment objectives, risks, charges and expenses
must be considered carefully before investing. The prospectus
contains this and other important information about the investment
company, and it may be obtained from www.vicefund.com,
or by calling Shareholder Services toll free at 866-264-8783.
Read it carefully before investing.
Quasar Distributors, LLC, distributor. (01/08) |